Efficiency may be sometimes necessary, but rarely desirable- certainly not the hallmark of a culture, or of a well-lived life. Our house is full of complication and chaos and generally elaborate goings-on. Physical life is a messy business (eh bien!), and no one wants to miss out.
Not shying away from fuss or festivity in our house, complicated desserts like the dacquoise or tall layered cake or Paris-Brest show up regularly. But our table is sadly rather often pie-less. The truth is that pie crust is a tricky thing to get just right and easy to get wrong- overworked, tough- and particularly in the heat of summer when you'd want it most. But just this week I read a recipe for (Southern, not British) biscuits in the new issue of Cooks Illustrated, using a method that I remember using for pie crust a couple for decades ago and although it worked like a charm I forgot about it simply because it was at a time in life when the acquisition of new dishes was ever increasing. It is a delight to have it back, especially now that the plums are in- the finest of pie fruits baking up all jammy. Not so very much separates the poor dacquoise from the excellent one. Fruit pies on the other hand command a huge spectrum- The worst (and plenty to be had of them) are dreadful, the best are sublime, and so simple looking no one can imagine the effort and skill they so discretely display.
I love not schlepping the food processor around and washing it too. This recipe, suitable for even the hottest day, uses a hunk of frozen butter, and a simple box grater- the frozen butter is grated directly into your flour mixture and tossed up with it before it has a chance to even thaw, and some ice water is drizzled in with one hand while the other does more tossing and when you can just hold it together it is done, still cold- so cold that the only chill it needs is the quick rest in the refrigerator when you prepared the filling.
It is essential that small pieces of solid butter are dispersed throughout the dough- they melt, create steam, and this makes for flakiness. The right moment can be elusive. Not with the box grater though- this is foolproof- all the satisfaction on a hand tossed dough, none of the risk and frustration.
For our pie today we used:
250 g/ 2 C flour
3/4 tsp. salt
1 tablespoon sugar
170 g/ 3/4 C butter, frozen solid
80 ml/more or less a 1/3 C ice water
1 K/ 6 C plums
40 g/ 1/3 C flour
200 g/ 1 C sugar- if your fruit is quite sweet to taste, use a little less
a dash of salt
some vanilla and some bitter almond
or
a few gratings of fresh nutmeg and a little cinnamon
3 Tablespoons of coarse sugar- like demerara, for the top of the crust
Freezing the butter is essential. Keeping butter in the freezer is great anyway, pie or not- it keeps fresh for months and months, and thaws quickly when you need it. Having everything chilled, especially on a warm day, makes it easier to work with and turns out a perfect product. Mix the flour with the salt and sugar (if it is a very hot day, freeze this, too). Grate the butter on the large holes of a box grater directly into the flour, giving it a toss mid-way through, and tossing again so the butter is in separate long pieces, evenly distributed throughout the flour. This takes about half a minute.
 |
Toss the butter into the flour right away- that pretty tangle of separate strips of butter will quickly meld together. |
Have ice water (truly with ice cubes- the colder the better) ready. While the one hand tosses the flour and butter mixture, the other hand drizzles in the chilled water. 80 ml/ 1/3 C should be enough for it to make a dough that just holds together when pressed into a ball, if not, add another spoonful. Make sure to get all the way down to the bottom of the bowl. Pat gently into a rough disk, wrap in plastic and put in the refrigerator until you need it or, if you are using it right away, in the freezer while you prepare the fruit. When you are ready to roll out the dough and assemble the galette, heat the oven to 200 C/400 F- pie needs a nice hot oven to crisp the crust.
Cut the plums, pit them, and leave them in rough chunks of varying size. Here we have 2 varieties- tiny Italian prune-plums and larger red plums. Add the sugar, flour, flavorings, and a small dash of salt, and toss together.
To make a simple pie even simpler, roll the dough out directly on the parchment the pie will be baked on. Cut a square of non-stick baking paper the size of your largest flat pan, put it on the counter, and flour it and the surrounding counter very well. Put the disk of dough in the middle, flour it also, and roll to about half again as large as the pie you want.
You need a little structure to hold in all fruit- don't roll too thin.The edges will spread beyond the paper. Carefully transfer the paper and disc of dough on to the baking sheet, pile the fruit into the center leaving a large border of dough around it, and fold these sides in, any which way. Clean any fruit/sugar juices off your hands first- any on the crust will blacken like coal in the oven.
Although much simpler to shape and so much more informal than a crimped and fluted crusted pie, this casual messy galette is no less elegant. Uncontained, it has glorious dimensions. It is a fine option when making a 2-crusted fluted and lattice topped classic pie would simply be overwhelming.
Not necessary, but dazzling and easy and very delicious is to coat the crust with coarse sugar before baking. Wet your hands, pat the surface of the crust all over, and sprinkle generously with coarse sugar.
The surface of the crust will puff up all beautifully golden as it bakes-
Bake for certainly 40 minutes and they sometimes need nearly an hour- the crust should be richly golden all over, not at all browned. Watching during the last 10 or 15 minutes of baking. The thickened juices will have invariable gushed out in one or two spots- this is the most delicious part of the pie- scrape them up with a spoon and serve them with each piece. If you leave them they will turn to a chewy sheet of intense fruit essence.
 |
Ours has collapsed altogether here on the right- rolling the crust thicker would have prevented this. |
This is a fabulous last-minute dessert made of any stone fruits or apples or pears you have around (pears are very delicious like this), or berries- a mix is also nice. You can slip it into the oven while you are at the table and have it warm and smelling of butter for dessert. But nothing is so nice as cold pie for breakfast.
The same crust, doubled:
Apple Pie with Rum and Beurre Noisette